VALIDATION DATA

MEASUREMENT PROPERTIES
Limitations English only
Observations
1. RELIABILITY
A. Internal Consistency Tested
Cronbach's (Describe)

Cronbach alpha of 0. 87 for hip and knee osteoarthritis.

B. Reliability intraobserver or test-retest Tested
Continuous scores: intraclass
correlation coefficient (ICC)
Dichotomus: Cohen kappa (Describe)

Short term (~4 week) retest reliability ICC=0.64 (95% CI 0.67, 0.86)

C. Reliability interobserver or Measurement error Tested
Standard error of measurement (SEM),
smallest detectable change (SDC) or
Limits of agreement (LoA) (Describe)

In random samples of patients from the same sites who had made decisions, the correlations of the SDMP_4 scores averaged .61.

2. VALIDITY
A. Content validity: face validity Tested
Expert opinion (relevance and
comprehensiveness) (Describe)

Content validity was confirmed through the extensive feedback from patients and providers in the development process as well as in the field tests. The survey is feasible and typically has very low missing data (1-3%).

B. Construct Validity:
Structural validity
Tested
Hypotheses-testing Tested
Cross-cultural validity Not Tested
Brief Description

To assess construct validity, they hypothesized that patients who made an Informed Patient-Centered (IPC) Decision would have higher SDM scores. For Hips/Knees and Backs, patients who made an IPC Decision had significantly higher SDMP and SURE scores (p<0.001), but this relationship was not significant for either condition for CollaboRATE (Hips/Knees: p=0.24 and Backs: p=0.25).

C. Criterion validity Tested
Comparison with a 'gold standard' Continuous scores:
correlations, ROC curves Dichotomus:
Sensitivity & Specificity (Describe)

For hips/knees, the SDMP score was significantly associated with viewing all of the patient decision aid compared with those who did not (P < 0.001). Both scores were significantly associated with less regret and higher satisfaction (P < 0.001) for hips/knees.